In an era where many automotive manufacturers have moved towards producing smaller engines like the V6 or turbocharged inline-4, BMW has maintained its dedication to the traditional inline-6 engine.
the best six-cylinder engine
Since the 1930s, this inline-six engine has been continuously produced by the Bavarian company. Offering better equilibrium and requiring less components compared to a V-engine, it ensures smoother power distribution. This versatile engine suits various applications, ranging from rugged off-road vehicles to high-performance cars.
BMW’s lineup includes several notable models with this configuration, but one standout engine during its era was the M54, manufactured between 2000 and 2006. Typically, BMW engines earn praise for their robustness; however, the M54 particularly impressed due to its excellent combination of performance and fuel economy right out of the box. Additionally, it offered extensive customization possibilities which appealed greatly to enthusiasts looking to modify their vehicles. For those who kept these cars over extended periods, the M54 also garnered an impressive track record for durability. Although it may lack some sophistication compared to newer variants like the B58, could the M54 still hold advantages making it preferable?
Fortunately, the B58 has also proven to be a dependable piece of machinery over the long haul, and across its 10-year (and counting) lifespan, it does not appear to have developed any major problems. So in terms of reliability, which of these two engines you have matters less than making sure you bring it in for maintenance regularly.
Read more:
The Most Unreliable Cars, Trucks, and SUVs You Can Purchase in 2025, Per Consumer Reports
What Are Some Common Issues?
Although both engines boast excellent durability, each has some potential concerns. The B58 can experience sudden drops in coolant level within the main reservoir, potentially causing an engine overheat. Interestingly, related common issues include failure of the valve cover gaskets because of excessive heat. Nevertheless, this is not significantly dissimilar to what was observed with the M54; during its production run, it faced comparable challenges. It’s worth noting though that such complications did not occur very often in either model.
Both engines also utilize BMW’s VANOS system.
a adjustable valve timing mechanism
Considering its intricacy, it’s understandable that it often becomes a typical area for breakdowns, especially concerning its solenoids, which manage the oil pressure within the system. The contemporary B58 iteration of this setup is more sophisticated and somewhat trickier to fix compared to the older M54 model; however, this difficulty should not deter you if you’re contemplating the initial engine design.
Want more like this?
Join the Jalopnik newsletter
To receive the most recent automobile updates directly in your mailbox…
Read the
original article on Jalopnik
.
